From Flyers to Pies we’ve got the slice on Deep Dish: A Guide to the Best Pizza on Cape Cod

From Flyers to Pies we’ve got the slice on Deep Dish: A Guide to the Best Pizza on Cape Cod

🍕 Cape Cod Pizza Guide: Best Pizza Spots from Falmouth to Orleans

By Jeanette Robinson · July 2025

There’s something timeless about pizza. Whether you’re eight or eighty, nothing brings people together quite like a warm, cheesy slice—and here on Cape Cod, we do it with flair. From coal-fired crusts to rooftop garden toppings, the local pizza scene is as diverse as it is delicious.

Whether you’re a Neapolitan purist, a seafood-lover, or just looking for a post-beach bite, here are some of our favorite pizza spots across the Cape—and one just around the corner from the inn.

🍕

Pizza By Evan – Buzzards Bay

Start your Cape Cod pizza adventure as soon as you cross the Bourne Bridge. Located at 170 Clay Pond Road, Pizza By Evan is known for both its traditional Italian pies and its signature “Flyers.” The menu is bold, creative, and filled with handmade crusts that keep locals and visitors coming back for more.

SEO Excerpt: Just over the Bourne Bridge, Pizza By Evan in Buzzards Bay offers hand-crafted pies and signature Flyers that kick off your Cape Cod trip with serious flavor.

🔥

Pizza Barbone – Hyannis

At the heart of Main Street in Hyannis is Pizza Barbone, where the magic happens inside a handcrafted Stefano Ferrara oven made from volcanic rock and ash from Mt. Vesuvius. Add fresh vegetables straight from their rooftop garden, and you’ve got a pizza experience that’s both fresh and unforgettable.

SEO Excerpt: Pizza Barbone in Hyannis serves up rooftop-fresh ingredients and wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas in a volcanic brick oven imported from Naples.

🍷

Wicked Restaurant & Wine Bar – Mashpee Commons

Wicked strikes a balance between cozy and upscale, with Neapolitan-style pizzas cooked in a 700-degree stone hearth oven. Their Fig & Prosciutto pie is a standout, combining Fontina, fig purée, baby arugula, and a balsamic glaze.

SEO Excerpt: Head to Wicked in Mashpee Commons for artisan fire-kissed pizza and a perfect wine pairing in a stylish, relaxed setting.

🇬🇷

Estia Taverna – Mashpee & Falmouth

Coal-fired and Greek-inspired, Estia Taverna offers thin-crust pizzas with serious flavor. Try a classic Margherita or go bold with shrimp, feta, and oregano. The Falmouth location, just down the street from the inn, makes for a perfect dinner stop after a day of exploring.

SEO Excerpt: Estia Taverna in Falmouth and Mashpee blends modern Greek cuisine with coal-fired pizza for a unique Cape Cod dining experience.

🍕

Palio Pizzeria – Hyannis

For those craving a throwback to the no-frills, mom-and-pop pizza shop, Palio Pizzeria is it. Known for their brick oven pies and casual vibe, they offer classics like BBQ Chicken and unique picks like the Cape Codder, with garlic, shrimp, clams, and lemon.

SEO Excerpt: Palio Pizzeria in Hyannis delivers classic brick-oven pizza with laid-back charm and fresh local ingredients.

🌟

Jack’s Restaurant – Falmouth

A neighborhood favorite and just a few minutes’ drive from Frederick William House, Jack’s Restaurant is where we go when we want great pizza without the fuss. Their thin crust pies are loaded with flavor, whether you’re in the mood for a traditional pepperoni or something a little more gourmet. It’s the kind of place where locals mix with travelers—and one visit often turns into three.

SEO Excerpt: Jack’s Restaurant in Falmouth is a hidden gem near the bike path, serving up crave-worthy pizza just steps from Frederick William House.

🐾

Lost Dog Pub – Dennis & Orleans

With its relaxed pub atmosphere, live music, and classic New England charm, Lost Dog Pub makes pizza part of the party. Their signature Kitchen Sink pie really does come with everything—and somehow, it works.

SEO Excerpt: The Lost Dog Pub offers great pizza, cold drinks, and a local vibe in both Dennis and Orleans—perfect after a beach day.

🍺

Bad Martha Farmer’s Brewery – Falmouth

If your perfect evening includes artisan pizza, a craft beer, and a little live music, Bad Martha’s has you covered. Just a short drive from the inn, this laid-back brewery has become a local hangout, with theme nights and outdoor games that make it easy to linger.

SEO Excerpt: Bad Martha’s in Falmouth pairs fresh pizza with local beer and live music in a relaxed, dog-friendly setting.

🔥

Rock Harbor Grill – Orleans

Known for their elevated take on comfort food, Rock Harbor Grill delivers on every level. The wood-fired pizzas are just the beginning—this is a place where serious culinary skill meets a casual, welcoming vibe.

SEO Excerpt: Rock Harbor Grill in Orleans crafts gourmet wood-fired pizza with seasonal ingredients and a warm, welcoming feel.

🌿 Staying in Falmouth?

Frederick William House is ideally located to explore all of these pizza spots and more. Nestled along the Shining Sea Bikeway in Falmouth, our boutique inn is just steps from some of the Cape’s best restaurants, beaches, and bike trails. Come for the food, stay for the comfort.

🍔 Hungry for More?

• Best Burgers on Cape Cod

• Best Fish & Chips on Cape Cod